Wuthering Waves Lily vs. Shorekeeper: Choosing S0, S1, S2, or S3
Resonators

Wuthering Waves Lily vs. Shorekeeper: Choosing S0, S1, S2, or S3

KUKJIN LEE·November 14, 2026

The first question when considering Lily is often whether she's stronger than Shorekeeper. But S0, S2, and S3 improve different things. S0 secures her support role; S2 adds team Crit stats; S3 changes how she prepares and swaps out.

Separate three questions: how much she improves one team in Shorekeeper's place, whether she frees Shorekeeper for another team, and whether you want to invest further to shorten Lily's field time. That clarifies reasons to stop at S0 or continue to S3.

Lily combines healing, grouping, and team-specific support

Lily is a Spectro pistol Resonator who heals, pulls enemies together, and supports damage. Her Outro grants the team 25% All DMG Amplification for 30 seconds. After her Resonance Liberation, teammates' Intro Skills also build ATK-support stacks.

Not every effect reaches its maximum simply by adding her to the team. Some scale with Energy Regen, and some require teammates' Intros. Even with identical equipment, swap order can change how much support reaches the carry's main attack.

She has additional support for Unison users and Echo Skill-focused characters. In particular, the Echo Crit support applies to Echo Skill damage. Reading that as a universal Crit buff covering Normal Attacks and Resonance Liberation overstates S0's performance.

That makes her specialized effects relevant to Hsin–Suoming Unison teams and Echo-focused teams such as Sigrika's. If your team's damage comes mainly from elsewhere, assess whether the benefits excluding those specialized effects are sufficient.

Match Resonance Chains and weapons before comparing Shorekeeper

Shorekeeper supports Crit Rate and Crit DMG by upgrading her Liberation field in stages. Lily emphasizes ATK stacks, Outro amplification, and team-specific additions. The bigger individual stat doesn't automatically determine final damage.

Comparison conditionWhy it matters
S0 versus additional Resonance ChainsIncluding S2+ Shorekeeper support as if it were S0 changes the comparison
Signature versus alternative weaponsWeapon team buffs can be mixed into the apparent character-swap benefit
The carry's Crit setupRemoving Shorekeeper may leave insufficient Crit Rate
Stacks when the major attack landsA fully stacked showcase hit differs from an early attack before setup

A carry built around Shorekeeper's Crit Rate may crit less often when moved unchanged to S0 Lily. Selecting only a lucky large crit misses consistency across the actual fight.

Don't apply a high-chain carry's absolute damage gap directly to an S0 carry either. A larger hit and the percentage gain across a full rotation are different metrics. Compare peak hits alongside repeated team performance.

S1 changes how quickly stacks arrive, not the cap

S1 grants interruption immunity during a particular Heavy Attack and lets each other teammate's Intro add two ATK stacks while Lily's Liberation buff is active. S0 gains one, so fewer Intros are needed to reach the four-stack cap.

The maximum stack count itself doesn't double. A hit taken after both versions already reached four stacks may show little of S1's acceleration. The difference is how many stacks are ready before the carry's main attack.

For example, after two teammate Intros, S0 can have two stacks while S1 has four. If a longer sequence lets S0 reach the cap too, that gap narrows. S1 matters for shorter preparation, not merely one fully prepared peak hit.

Interruption immunity also deserves separate consideration. It reduces enemies interrupting the setup animation, but isn't invulnerability that prevents all incoming damage. Assess whether your team needs faster stacks, uninterrupted setup, or both.

S2's Crit stats aren't a final-damage percentage

Edited official Lily Resonance Liberation scene illustrating the difference between S2 buffs and S3 rotation changes

S2 adds 2% Crit Rate and 6% Crit DMG per existing ATK-buff stack. At four stacks, that's 8% Crit Rate and 24% Crit DMG. S1's faster stacking also helps reach those benefits sooner.

You can't add 8 and 24 and call it 32% more damage. Crit Rate changes the chance of a crit; Crit DMG changes its multiplier. Average gain depends on the carry's starting stats.

A carry already near the Crit Rate cap with other buffs may waste part of the extra rate. A team that lost needed Crit Rate on moving to S0 Lily may gain more flexibility from S2. The same chain level starts from different account conditions.

Check the carry's buffed Crit Rate, stacks actually maintained, and timing of major attacks. Attractive maximum stats and having them available at the right moment every rotation aren't the same.

S3 can shorten both the opening and the next return

Edited official Lily combat demonstration illustrating separate opening and return rotations

S3 gives 170 additional Forte resource on entering combat and another 170 on returning with the enhanced Intro after Liberation. The combat-entry gain triggers once every 12 seconds. It also adds Concerto Energy through Liberation, Resonance Energy on the Heavy Attack finisher's hit, and faster resource gain during Heavy Attacks.

This changes more than one attack multiplier. Starting with extra resources can reduce preparatory Normal Attacks and the time spent repeating setup on return. It also affects filling Concerto Energy to pass into the next character's Intro.

Don't memorize the opening and return as identical inputs. The first entry has no enhanced Intro prepared by an earlier Liberation; a later return may retain effects and energy from the preceding cycle. A faster opener and smooth later rotations are separate checks.

Measure entry-to-swap time for both the opening and the return. Then ask whether the saved field time becomes extra carry uptime. If another teammate's cooldown is still the bottleneck, Lily exiting sooner won't shorten the entire cycle equally.

S3 is therefore an investment for rotation refinement, not a requirement to unlock a support role absent at S0. Separate the cost of S2's damage support from the further cost of shortening setup.

Assess one team's performance and multi-team allocation separately

Hsin, Suoming, and Lily combine Unison support with stacks from teammate Intros. Go beyond simply replacing Shorekeeper: decide who uses an Intro first and how many stacks the main attack receives.

Sigrika teams can use Lily's Echo Skill damage support. But pairing Sigrika with Qiuyuan versus Lucilla, and choosing when to use Echo Skills, changes the sequence. One teammate configuration doesn't represent every Sigrika team.

Multi-team content creates another benefit. Placing Lily on one side can leave Shorekeeper with another main team and improve a team previously relying on a weaker support. That's an account-wide improvement separate from any direct Lily-versus-Shorekeeper percentage.

If you run few teams and existing healers and supports cover every slot, a second support may matter less. The practical question is whether any team is actually held back by support shortage, not how many carries you own.

Separate reasons to obtain S0 from reasons to invest further

Consider S0 if you need healing, grouping, and team support, if Unison or Echo teams suit her, or if reallocating Shorekeeper improves your roster. A signature weapon is another cost and should be assessed separately from obtaining Lily herself.

For further chains, define the problem: S1 for slow stack-building, S2 for additional general Crit support, or S3 for shorter setup and return time. Higher investment doesn't deliver the same percentage gain to every account.

Fill the support role first, then invest in a weakness you actually experience. Rather than choosing a chain target from a huge damage showcase, ask whether your team lacks buffs or preparation time. That is a more durable way to compare Lily and Shorekeeper.