What was their first Roblox game? Reading three developers’ Roblox Replay cards
Guides

What was their first Roblox game? Reading three developers’ Roblox Replay cards

KUKJIN LEE·November 21, 2026

Builderman and Shedletsky have the same first card in Roblox Replay: Sword Fights on the Heights IV, the sword-fighting game played across floating platforms and narrow bridges. Shedletsky made it himself. Erik Cassel’s first card goes in quite a different direction, to an old map where Sonic and Shadow can eat you.

Does that tell us what all three did on their very first day? The distinction is in “first card.” Roblox Replay finds experiences through badges left on an account. If your first visit earned no badge, the first game you remember can easily differ from the one Replay finds.

What appears on four developers’ lists

AccountExperience shown in ReplayWhat the card establishes
buildermanSword Fights on the Heights IVIt appears on the first card.
ShedletskySword Fights on the Heights IVHis first card shows his own creation.
erik.casselFeed Sonic and Shadow or be Eaten!Sonic and Shadow appear in the experience on the first card.
Matt DusekAn early card shows a spaceship.It’s marked “2nd.” The first title hasn’t been identified.

It’s fun to imagine the two developers meeting on those bridges. Two cards don’t tell us they shared a server or played at the same time. They do let us pin down which experience it was. Another Shedletsky sword-fighting game includes “Original” in its title. The one on both cards ends in the Roman numeral IV. Those two letters matter when you go looking for the old map.

Erik Cassel’s result may surprise anyone who remembers early Roblox primarily for sword fights. In the Sonic game on his card, giant characters swallow you and you explore a block-built space. A familiar character can jog your memory of a whole genre. The card says nothing about how long he stayed or whether it was a favorite.

A sword-fighting badge you can earn by looking for a signature

A gold badge with a lighthouse illustrates the difference between a first visit and a first badge

One badge in Sword Fights on the Heights IV is John, Loved of Muses. You earn it by finding the creator’s signature on the map. There’s a separate badge for defeating five opponents. A player exploring every corner and another dueling on a bridge could leave a badge trail to the very same game.

The dates make the difference clear. The experience was created in March 2008, but the signature badge dates from August 2009. A player who explored the platforms between those dates couldn’t have earned it, however long they stayed. If they came back later and found the signature, the badge would remember their return visit.

We don’t know that the signature badge was either developer’s first. Their cards identify the experience. Finding the signature is just one way an account could have picked up a badge there. A record can point to the right game even when your memory of visiting goes back further.

How to find an early Roblox game on your own account

Search Roblox for Roblox Replay and open the experience by nktu. Read the first card, then use the right arrow to browse the next few. To look up another account, enter its username in Search inside the experience. Other-account searches may slow down when many people are using them.

If an experience you remember is missing at first, check how much of the list has loaded. The creator says most entries arrive within ten minutes and the full list can take up to an hour. If you just want one old map, you can open it as soon as its title and picture turn up. To compare the oldest entries, give the full list time to load.

Similar titles? Check the number in the game link. The sword-fighting experience on both first cards has place ID 47324. The similarly named Original has place ID 487316. If an old link you shared with a friend contains 47324, it points to the same place even if the thumbnail has changed.

When the dates don’t match, read the badge requirement

Imagine visiting a lighthouse map and spending the whole first day sailing around the harbor. You return a week later and switch on the light for the first time. A badge for lighting the beacon will carry that later date. Play a different game with a welcome badge in between, and that later visit will come first in badge order.

When the first card looks unfamiliar, read the badge name alongside its condition. “Welcome” might bring back the view as you arrived. “Light the Beacon” might remind you of the climb. An experience where you earned no badge can remain missing however long you wait for this list.

The best find might be several cards in: a title you’ve forgotten, but a bridge you remember crossing. Save the game name and the place ID together. Next time you want to visit, you won’t have to remember which card it was.