When facing the Agent of Judgment in the first half of Chaos Zero Nightmare Season 5’s Great Rift, you may notice the number on an Original Sin card dropping as expected—then suddenly your entire hand disappears. The number you need to reduce to 0 is the boss’s Sin. The cost of the Original Sin card in your hand tells you how many more times you can play cards under that condition. Keeping the two separate can change when you should play even a 0-cost card.
For the Vanguard, start with cards that reduce Tenacity or apply damage-over-time effects. For the Rearguard, start Turn 1 with a non-Attack card. If Original Sin appears again on Turn 3, use card draw effects first. Keep these three conditions handy during the fight:
| Battle Phase | Action that reduces Sin with the first Original Sin | Action that reduces Sin with the second Original Sin |
|---|---|---|
| Vanguard | Reduce Tenacity or apply a damage-over-time effect with a card. Reduce Sin by up to 3 per card | Reduce Sin by 2 each time you play an Attack card |
| Rearguard, first cycle | Reduce by 1 for each non-Attack card activated | Reduce by 1 for each card created by a card effect |
| Original Sin that reappears starting on Turn 3 for the Rearguard | Reduce by 2 for each card drawn by a card effect | Reduce by 1 for each card created by a card effect |
If Original Sin costs 1, when will the next card activate?
Original Sin is a status card that enters your hand. Each time you activate another card, its cost decreases by 1. When the first Original Sin reaches 0, it switches to the second Original Sin. Sin is a stack on the boss that decreases when you meet the condition listed on the current Original Sin. The Vanguard starts with 15 Sin stacks, and each of the two Original Sins costs 9. A single card can remove multiple stacks, so you don’t need to set aside 15 separate cards that meet the conditions.
For example, suppose the Vanguard’s first Original Sin costs 1, and you have one card that deals Tenacity damage and one Attack card that doesn’t. If you play the card that deals Tenacity damage first, you’ll get the benefit of the first condition, then you can remove 2 more Sin with the other Attack card under the second Original Sin that just appeared. Play them in the opposite order, and those same two cards will miss the chance to reduce Sin under the first condition. When the cost is 1, you’re choosing the last card that meets the current Original Sin’s condition.
If the boss’s Sin stays the same while Original Sin switches over, check the current condition before playing more cards just because you can. Activating a card that doesn’t meet the condition can also add Guilt, making the boss’s attacks stronger. If any Sin remains when the second Original Sin reaches 0, the cards you’ve saved in your hand are removed and the boss launches a powerful attack. But you can’t just keep ending your turns until you get a good hand, either. “Unfair Trial” decreases at the start of each turn, bringing the boss’s judgment closer.
Cards you plan to use for damage have another cost interaction to watch. In this Great Rift, Herald of Judgment takes reduced damage when a card is activated with a higher Cost than its original Cost. Using an attack that originally costs 2 is different from increasing a 1-Cost attack to 2, even though both show the same number in your hand. If you’ve removed Sin effectively but your main attack is dealing unusually little damage, check whether its Cost has been increased.
Vanguard: Plan which attacks to save for the Second Original Sin
For the first phase, focus less on Attack and more on how much Tenacity damage the card deals and whether it applies a new DoT effect. An existing DoT triggering again later is different from a card applying that effect now. The condition in this phase is to reduce Tenacity or apply a DoT effect by activating cards. That’s why Tenacity-focused Combatants like Sereniel and DoT-appliers like Arabella are both good candidates.
The Second Original Sin makes the math easier. If 6 Sin remain, you need to activate three Attack cards; if 5 remain, you still need three. You don’t have to have all three cards in your hand at once—you just need to be able to activate three within the remaining Original Sin Cost. Even if one card hits multiple times, each activation of an Attack card counts as one. So if 2 Sin remain and a single card can clear them, there’s less reason to use an expensive main attack. A low-Cost attack can clear those 2 Sin, too.
This calculation can also help when adjusting your Vanguard deck. If you still have attacks to play during the Second Original Sin but keep falling just short on Sin, first check how many times you actually reduced Tenacity in the first phase. On the other hand, if the First Original Sin goes smoothly but you run out of cards during the Second, consider whether you played every Attack card in the first phase just because you could. Even with the same three Combatants, the outcome can change depending on which cards you have left in hand when the First Original Sin ends.
The Rearguard has different support requirements on Turn 1 and draw requirements on Turn 3

The Rearguard’s first Original Sin on Turn 1 is “Support.” Activating a non-Attack card reduces Sin by 1, so even a Support card that doesn’t draw cards still does its job here. The second Original Sin is “Create.” Distinguish cards moved from the draw pile to your hand from cards newly created by card effects. Even if your hand grows by two cards, drawing two from your deck reduces Sin by 0 for the Create condition.
When Original Sin appears again on Turn 3, its first condition changes to “Draw.” A Support card in your hand now leaves Sin unchanged if it only heals. Draw two cards with a card effect, and Sin goes down by 4. The second Original Sin, however, is once again “Create,” so an effect that creates two new cards reduces Sin by 2. That’s why repeatedly playing draw cards that worked well for the previous condition quickly reduces only the second Original Sin’s cost.
For example, say the first Original Sin is about to expire, and you have a card that draws two cards and a card that creates three cards. Draw first to reduce the remaining Sin, then play the create card when the second Original Sin appears. That way, each effect meets the condition for the right phase. Of course, if a single draw already reduces Sin to 0, the card that changes in your hand becomes Atonement. At that point, there’s no reason to play the create card you were saving just for that condition.
Rossweisse’s “Sword Resonance” is a good example for understanding the create-card phase. If the setup creates three Sword Counters, one activation creates all three. Blazebell’s “Fluttering Embers” only grants its base draw when your hand contains cards of the same attribute and activates Purity. On Turn 1, simply playing a non-Attack card helps, but on Turn 3, you also need to check whether your hand can actually draw cards. The same principle applies when using Rossweisse, Blazebell, and Tiphera together. There’s a one-card difference between having all three combatants in your party and activating their effects at the moment you want.
Until Atonement disappears after all Sin is cleared
Once you clear all Sin, Original Sin changes into Atonement, and the boss prepares a weakened attack. If you use your whole hand right away, Bleed cards may get mixed in on the next turn. While Atonement remains in your hand, activating certain types of cards increases its Cost. When the boss uses “Atonement’s Punishment,” Bleed cards equal to that Cost are added to your Draw Pile.
During this short phase, the Vanguard and Rearguard need to play their hands in opposite orders. The Vanguard’s Atonement Cost increases when you play a Skill card. You need to pass the action count, so if you have an Attack card in hand, this is a good time to use it. The Rearguard’s Atonement Cost increases when you play an Attack card. In the Rearguard, you can pass the count with a draw or a Skill that sets up your next attack, then bring out Rossweisse’s main Attack after Atonement disappears.
Even if Atonement’s Cost is 0 when you take the punishment, the boss’s attack still hits. What you’ve reduced is the number of Bleed cards added to your deck afterward. Conversely, if the Vanguard can deal enough damage to end the battle immediately, you can defeat the boss before Bleed gets mixed into your next hand. That kind of finish is difficult against the Rearguard boss in Merit Battle, which has infinite HP. Even with the same hand, how many more turns you have to play changes when you should use your main damage card.
Bringing your Subjugation Battle rotation into Merit Battle
The first half of the Great Rift runs from after maintenance on November 11 until before maintenance on December 2 (KST, UTC+9; 日本時間). In Subjugation Battle, both the Vanguard and Rearguard can defeat the boss, and there are no seasonal restrictions on Save Data, making it a good place to practice the conditions with a familiar deck. Defeating the Rearguard boss for the first time in Subjugation Battle unlocks Merit Battle, where you compete for rankings. In the Rearguard of Merit Battle, you can use Save Data from the current season or the default Save Data. That’s why, if you cleared Subjugation Battle with a deck from an earlier season, you should first check whether that same card setup is available in Merit Battle.
When you're putting together your first team, you can copy the game's recommended lineup or load one from a preset. After that, pick a moment when your score fell short of expectations. If your hand ran out at the end of the second Original Sin, that may be a clue about when you used your card-generation or Attack Cards. If you cleared Sin stacks efficiently but then drew a hand full of Bleed, think back to the types of cards you played while Atonement was in your hand before changing your deck. If the Rearguard only feels smooth on the first turn, the first thing to check is whether you actually drew cards on turn 3. Once you know where you got stuck, you can pinpoint one card to change in your next run.
